Your Good Health: No proof high-dose vitamin C prevents Alzheimer’s – Times Colonist
Dear Dr. Roach: Is there any evidence that high doses of vitamin C have decreased the risk of or prevented Alzheimer’s disease? None of the people I know who have developed Alzheimer’s have been taking high doses of vitamin C daily (4,000 to 6,000 milligrams).
So, I wonder if this safe, inexpensive, natural remedy, found in health-food stores could have stopped these tragedies by preventing atherosclerosis in the brain.
Many people have had the same idea, and it has been the subject of scientific study. A recent review of the many studies that have been done shows that a diet rich in vitamin C (and other nutrients) is of benefit in helping prevent dementia (including Alzheimer’s).
However, taking supplements, even high-dose supplements, is unlikely to have any additional benefit over a healthy diet. Most of the studies showed no benefit of vitamin C compared with placebo.
I don’t recommend vitamin supplementation for the purposes of preventing Alzheimer’s disease.
Dear Dr. Roach: I was considering getting a DNA test in order to get personalized diet recommendations. It’s very expensive. Do you think it’s worth it?
In theory, it’s a great idea. Knowing about our precise genetic makeup might allow for personalized recommendations not only on diet, but also on exercise, medication and medical treatments.
But in practice, the science is in its infancy. There are a few genes identified that predict better outcomes with one treatment or another and that can identify metabolism of medications, but for the specific indication of choosing the best diet, I don’t know of any good evidence that the diet recommended by the results of genetic testing has any better outcome than a diet that would be recommended for someone in general.
Until there is solid evidence of benefit, I’d recommend saving your money.
Dear Dr. Roach: I have a family member who is an alcoholic. One year ago, he stopped drinking copious amounts of beer on a daily basis. Since then, he drinks only non-alcoholic beer every day, but continues to consume large volumes of this.
Even though it contains less than 0.5 per cent alcohol by volume, is this harming him in any way?
Is he addicted to it due to the fact that there is still a very small amount of alcohol content? Is it OK for a recovering alcoholic to drink this?
Non-alcoholic beer has very, very little alcohol, and at least one brand, Kirin Free, has no alcohol at all.
It would be very difficult to become intoxicated with non-alcoholic beer. A typical non-alcoholic beer has about 1.5 grams of alcohol, meaning 10 of these beverages would have the alcohol in one standard drink.
Intoxication is unlikely, due to the stomach and liver having the ability to metabolize the alcohol.
However, these beverages do contain sugars and calories, so drinking 10 isn’t recommended for overall health.
That being said, your family member has made a large improvement in his health, and I think he would benefit from support, encouragement and congratulations.
Dr. Roach regrets that he is unable to answer individual letters, but will incorporate them in the column whenever possible. Readers may email questions to ToYourGoodHealth@med.cornell.edu.